A personal insight into various issues relevant to children with cancer, their families and health professionals involved in their care in India
Monday, 6 June 2022
5 Types of Paediatric Cancer You Need to Know About
Sunday, 5 June 2022
Childhood cancer can be treated
I am in the process of bringing all y blog posts in one place. Here is something I wrote a few years ago on the Max Healthcare platform.
https://www.maxhealthcare.in/blogs/childhood-cancer-can-be-treated
It is intended for the general public. The types of cancer affecting children are quite different from the cancers that affect teenagers and young adults. Childhood cancers have become a menace. However, a lot of progress has been made in treating childhood cancers in the recent decades
Monday, 11 April 2022
SAFER Ukraine - The Power of the Global Pediatric Oncology Community
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Ukrainian_refugee_crisis "More than 4.5 million refugees have since left Ukraine (as of 9 April 2022), while an estimated 6.5 million people have been displaced within the country (as of 18 March 2022). In total, more than ten million people – approximately one-quarter of the country's total population – had left their homes in Ukraine by 20 March. By 24 March 2022, according to UNICEF, more than half of all Ukrainian children had been forced to leave their homes."
SAFER Ukraine has established a virtual command center to coordinate evacuations and ensure treatment continues for pediatric oncology patients. The process includes determining transportation logistics and identifying high-risk patients who are deteriorating. The SAFER Ukraine team and volunteers translate medical records, coordinate departure travel and manage the logistics of transport across the border. In addition to the above efforts, the team also established a triage clinic in Poland. Patients and their families can rest and recover from the evacuation while awaiting assignment to a clinic for continued treatment.
Tuesday, 15 March 2022
Dinutuximab (Anti GD2 therapy) for children with high risk neuroblastoma now available in India
High risk neuroblastoma continues to be a childhood cancer which is challenging to treat and has poor outcomes. While smaller increments in survival have been made over the years, a big step-up in survival was when Anti-GD2 therapy (now known as Dinutuximab) was introduced and this was published by Yu et al in this landmark study. I had written a blog on this in 2010 and also reflected on the Indian situation. Since then Dinutuximab has become the standard of care for high risk neuroblastoma in high-income countries.
Low and middle income countries like India have not had access to the medicine, either through clinical trials, or through compassionate use. This has now changed and the first child received Dinutuximab in Mumbai last year and this was covered in the media - Mumbai child receives special injection to treat rare cancer. Subsequent to this, I have been informed that another child has received this treatment in Bangalore and there are a few others waiting to receive it.
While this is exciting and welcome, it is important to point out that AVAILABILITY does not equate to ACCESSIBILITY. And the main reason for that in this context is AFFORDABILITY. This drug is not manufactured in India but imported from Europe. Based on the information available to me, a child who weighs around 13 kg will need 3 vials per cycle and a total of 15 vials for 5 cycles. With each vial 11,000 Euros, the total cost is approximately INR 1.4 cr + 25% custom duties. With the right kind of paper-work and eligibility for discount, the custom fees may be waived off and the price of the drug could come down to INR 56 lakh. But this still remains out of reach of almost all children with high risk neuroblastoma in India.
In conclusion, it is a welcome positive step that Dinutuximab in now available in India. With time and increased use, we hope and expect the price to be driven down so that it becomes accessible to more children who need it.
Monday, 28 February 2022
A Parents Guide to Childhood Cancer - The Max Institute of Cancer Care Version
Thursday, 15 October 2020
Milestones in Childhood Cancer Collaborative Research - Part 2
The 21st century has see the emergence of multi-centre collaborative research from low and middle income countries with reports from Central America, Africa, China and India. This is a very welcome development and I will briefly describe some of these initiatives below. But I would like to start with Brazil where cooperative groups for childhood cancer started in the 1980s.
The Brazilian Experience
The Cooperative Groups Initiative in Brazil started in 1980, allowing exchange of expertise and proposals of better care. There are seven well-established cooperative groups with ongoing protocols including the participation in international studies. Among their earliest works which was published in 1991 was the randomised controlled study on Single‐dose versus fractionated‐dose dactinomycin in the treatment of wilms' tumor with no significant difference in overall or relapse‐free survival. Shortly afterwards, they published the Treatment results of three consecutive Brazilian cooperative childhood ALL protocols: GBTLI-80, GBTLI-82 and -85 and were able to examine the role and dose of cranial radiation as well as treatment intensification.
For further reading - Brazilian Society of Pediatric Oncology - SOBOPE: 30 years of history, a lot in the present, full of the future and Pediatric hematology oncology in Brazil
Francophone Africa - The French‐African Pediatric Oncology Group (GFAOP)
The Franco-African Childhood Cancer Group (French acronym, GFAOP) was founded in 2000 with aim of improving the outcomes of children with cancer in Africa. The GFAOP has developed two forms of action. The main form consists of organizing two- to twelve-month training sessions for physicians and nurses in France and Morocco. The other form involves assessing the feasibility of modern treatment protocols for various cancers in Africa. The first feasibility trials were carried out on nephroblastoma and Burkitt's lymphoma in 12 pilot units in North Africa, West Africa, and Madagascar. In the first study from 2001 to 2004, 306 children of Burkitt's lymphoma using French LMB protocols adapted to the African setting and achieved a survival rate of 61% - Treatment of B‐cell lymphoma with LMB modified protocols in Africa—report of the French‐African Pediatric Oncology Group (GFAOP).
The SIOP PODC Africa Wilms Tumour Project
This project is implementing a SIOP PODC adapted treatment guideline for Wilms tumour in several centres in sub-Saharan Africa. This is done as a multi centre prospective clinical trial with uniform outcome evaluation. The project started in 2014. More than 300 patients have been included and treated. End of treatment survival without evidence of disease increased from 52% to 68%. Death during treatment decreased from 21% to 13% and abandonment of treatment from 23% to 13% - Improved outcome at end of treatment in the collaborative Wilms tumour Africa project
Asociación de Hemato‐Oncologiá Pediátrica de Centro América (AHOPCA)
For further reading - Asociación de Hemato-Oncología Pediátrica de Centro América (AHOPCA): a model for sustainable development in pediatric oncology
There are several other regional and national initiatives in pediatric oncology collaborative research in LMIC which have blossomed in recent years e.g. the Turkish Pediatric Oncology Group, The Pediatric Oncology East and Mediterranean (POEM) network and others. We look forward to seeing their work in the future. I would like to now focus on China and India, which together would constitute nearly a third of the childhood cancer burden. And so both of these countries have to strengthen their collaborative research so that they individually and the world collectively can aspire to reach the WHO Global Initiative for Childhood Cancer target of at least 60% survival by 2030.
The Chinese Experience
There are two national collaborative groups within China. The Chinese Children Leukemia Group (CCLG) started the CCLG-ALL 2008 Study. A total of 2231 patients were recruited from 10 hospitals across the country from 2008 to 2013 - Outcome of children with newly diagnosed acute lymphoblastic leukemia treated with CCLG-ALL 2008: The first nation-wide prospective multicenter study in China. More recently, the Chinese Children Cancer Group (CCCG) which was formed in In 1997 under the China Anti-Cancer Association, has organized one of the largest clinical trials in China, the CCCG-ALL-2015 Study. The study is led by the National Center for Children’s Health (Shanghai) and supported by St Jude Children’s Research Hospital and the VIVA Foundation. Up to January 2019, and 6024 patients were recruited into the study.
For further reading - Treatment of childhood cancer in China: Current status and future direction
Indian Pediatric Oncology Group (InPOG)
The earliest report of collaboration in the field of pediatric oncology in India was that between Cancer Institute, Chennai and the National Cancer Institute, USA in the early 1980s. Adopting a more intense protocol (MCP841) than that being used at the time, led to an improvement in the event free survival of acute lymphoblastic leukemia from 20% to 40%. This treatment strategy was then adopted by Tata Memorial Hospital, Mumbai in 1986 and All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi in 1992. With this common protocol, event free survival rates of 40-60% were achieved - Treatment of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia in countries with limited resources; lessons from use of a single protocol in India over a twenty year period.
The need to establish a national cooperative group in order to develop prospective multi-centre clinical trials in India became increasingly apparent. Such a strategy was critical to understand the biological differences in the disease, to assess responses to treatment and ultimately to improve childhood cancer survival in India. Active since 2015, the mission of InPOG is to improve the outcomes of children with cancer in India by collaborative research. At present here are 26 disease and discipline subcommittees with a portfolio of 31 studies.
The InPOG-HL-15-01 was amongst the first studies to start recruitment and standardised therapy of children with Hodgkin disease on an ABVD backbone – InPOG-HL-15-01 - Challenges and lessons learnt in setting up the first collaborative multicentre prospective clinical trial in childhood cancer in India. Initial results are expected to be published next year.
For further reading - Indian Pediatric Oncology Group (InPOG) - Collaborative research in India comes of age
The future looks very exciting. May this momentum gather an even greater speed!
Wednesday, 16 September 2020
Milestones in Childhood Cancer Collaborative Research - Part 1
September is Childhood Cancer Awareness Month and it is a good time to reflect on the progress we have made in curing childhood cancer and how we got here. An important part has been the ability of all stakeholders to get together and enroll children with cancer on to clinical trails, specially multicentre collaborative research. In this first part I look at some of the earliest works done in North America and Europe and highlight a few studies.
This all started in 1948 when Sidney Farber attempted to use a folate antagonist, Aminopterin to block the function of folic acid in patients with acute leukemia in hopes of achieving remission - Temporary remissions in acute leukemia in children produced by folic acid antagonist, 4-aminopteroyl-glutamic acid. Of 16 children, 10 demonstrated clinical, hematological and pathological evidence of improvement for three months. At that time this observation was met with disbelief and also it was felt to be unethical to "experiment" with the life of a child with leukemia when cure was not possible.
Thankfully, he and others like him continued in their efforts. The relative rarity of the disease and the need for shared expertise in management led to the creation of the first pediatric oncology co-perative groups (Cancer and Leukemia Group B Cooperative Group as well as the Acute leukemia Chemotherapy Cooperative Study Group A) in the US in 1955 which were the forerunners of the now well established and respected Children's Oncology Group. For the last 65 years, COG in North America and SIOP in Europe have increased our knowledge and understanding of childhood cancers and conducted studies which have improved outcomes. Here are some of the earliest studies:
Childhood Leukemia
Childhood Solid Tumours
Published in 1968, maintenance dactinomycin following surgery was found to be superior (continued remission rate of 86%) compared to when no maintenance was given (continued remission rate of 48%) - Single versus multiple dose dactinomycin therapy of Wilms's tumor. A controlled co-operative study conducted by the Children's Cancer Study Group A (formerly Acute Leukemia Co-operative Chemotherapy Group A)
Colleagues in Europe investigated the role of radiotherapy and actinomycin d (dactinomycin) in Wilms tumour - Preoperative versus postoperative radiotherapy, single versus multiple courses of actinomycin d, in the treatment of Wilms' tumor. Preliminary results of a controlled clinical trial conducted by the international society of paediatric oncology (S.I.O.P.). This was the first SIOP study and also the first international randomized trial in Europe. Pre-op radiotherapy reduced the tumour rupture rate at surgery. Also there was no added benefit of post-op radiotherapy after receiving pre-op radiotherapy.
Childhood CNS Tumours
Tait et al from SIOP examined adjuvant vincristine and CCNU in medulloblastoma - Adjuvant chemotherapy for medulloblastoma: The first multi-centre control trial of the International Society of Paediatric Oncology (SIOP I). Their results were that although there was no overall statistical difference between the two arms of the trial, a benefit for chemotherapy was seen in a number of sub-groups; partial or sub-total surgery, brainstem involvement , and stage T3 and T4 disease.
Childhood Cancer Survivors
Tuesday, 1 September 2020
Childhood Cancer Awareness Month: increasing survival rates for children with cancer
Saturday, 15 August 2020
Cancer and Childhood Cancer Care in India – FIVE reasons why I am POSITIVE and MOTIVATED on our 74th Independence day
Today we complete 73 years of our independent existence and celebrate our 74th Independence day. The strides we have made as a nation are truly enormous and are acknowledged widely. At the same time, the challenges which remain are no less mighty and we need to continue on the path of relentless progress to overcome hunger, poverty, ill health, strife, pollution, among others.
Thursday, 30 July 2020
Childhood cancer survivorship and late effects: The landscape in India in 2020
So far, the information from India has been limited and scattered. We mad an attempt to bring this all together and are happy to share our recent publication on this in the Pediatric Blood Cancer - Childhood cancer survivorship and late effects: The landscape in India in 2020
Sunday, 19 July 2020
COVID-19 Pandemic and Childhood Cancer
It will be some time before this comes to pass. Meanwhile children with cancer (like those with many other illnesses) have been caught in this maelstrom with impact on their diagnosis, their treatment and eventually outcomes. In the face of such ongoing challenges, the global and the national pediatric oncology community has got together to respond on multiple fronts in many different ways.
Tuesday, 10 March 2020
Podcast on perspectives of caregivers of children with cancer in India on their journey to accessing timely cancer diagnosis and treatment
I am glad to share a podcast https://www.ghccpod.com/22-the-labyrinth/ was conducted by Dr Mark Zobeck based on one our recent pieces of work in trying to understand the experiences of the caregivers of children with cancer in India as they obtain their diagnosis and start treatment.
I quote from his link
Sunday, 16 February 2020
Sunday, 18 February 2018
International Childhood Cancer Day 2018
15th Feb is celebrated as International Childhood Cancer Day every year across the world. This day celebrates those who have successfully conquered this disease and remembers those who did not make it. It spotlights the problem and the solutions. It brings together all stakeholders who are fighting to address this problem.
On this occasion several international and national organisations take a renewed pledge of commitment to these patients. Below are two press releases - the first by SIOP and CCI and the second by Cankids
Childhood Cancer International and SIOP are not alone in recognizing the devastating impact of childhood cancer on children and families around the globe. In September 2011, the United Nations (UN) General Assembly issued a Political Declaration recognizing four major Non-Communicable Diseases/NCDs (cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes and chronic respiratory disease) as the greatest killers of adults and children.
Sadly, childhood cancer continues to be the leading cause of non-communicable related death in children throughout the world. Globally, more than 300,000 children are diagnosed with cancer each year. Approximately 80 percent of our world’s children with cancer live in low-middle-income countries (LMICs) where more than 80 percent of these children die of their disease. In developed countries like the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Japan and others, more than 80 percent of children survive cancer with hope to live productive and meaningful lives.
On December 13, 2017 a new report from WHO and the World bank revealed that approximately half of the world’s population, including children, do not have access to essential health services and that 800 million people spend at minimum 10 percent of their household income on health-related care. Childhood cancers are often curable but too many children and adolescents have no hope to overcome their disease simply because they were born in a country entrenched in poverty resulting in late diagnosis, lack of access to life-saving essential medicines and appropriate treatment. As childhood cancer organizations, we know only too well that the associated cost to treat a child with cancer can be a burden that too many families simply can’t overcome. We support the need for universal access to essential medicines and healthcare for all children in the world diagnosed with cancer. In order for this to happen, CCI and SIOP agree that making childhood cancer a national and global child health priority is a critical first step towards increasing access to treatment and reducing childhood cancer mortality.
All children in the world deserve hope for a cure - no matter where they live - not more excuses. We can no longer sweep this issue “under the rug.” Children are the future of our country and our world. Their vitality is the heartbeat of our world, a shared passion that can unite us because our future as a global community depends on it.
On International Childhood Cancer Day, all members of Childhood Cancer International and SIOP stand united to make childhood cancer a national and global child health priority to ensure there are adequate resources to meet the basic rights of children with cancer. We believe those basic rights for all children diagnosed with cancer include:
- The right to early and proper diagnosis;
- The right to access life-saving essential medicines;
- The right to appropriate and quality medical treatments, and;
- The right to have access to sufficient palliative care;
- The right to follow up care, services and sustainable livelihood opportunities for survivors.
Sunday, 17 September 2017
Supporting Childhood Cancer Treatment in Punjab - Government of Punjab joins other Stakeholders
Over the last couple of years, Cankids has been actively engaging and lobbying with state governments – of Tamil Nadu and then Uttar Pradesh. Earlier this week they had a very fruitful meeting with the Punjab Government. I am sharing some news stories with you in this regard.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/punjab/cashless-cancer-treatment-for-all-below-18-punjab-health-minister/story-YeYJtKKcAbV584lwOqqneK.html
http://www.babushahi.com/full-news.php?id=63475&headline=Cashless-Cancer-treatment-for-children-at-18-empanelled-Punjab-hospitals
The Punjab government represented by the Punjab health minister Brahm Mohindra and his team joined the medical community – Dr Shruti Kakkar from DMC Ludhiana, Dr Joseph John from CMC Ludhiana, Dr Amita Mahajan from Apollo, New Delhi as well as Dr Scott Howard from World Child Cancer and International Society of Pediatric Oncology. The parent/patient support groups and civil society was represented by Cankids.
At a open meeting hosted at Government Medical College Patiala, several announcements were made including
- Extend cashless cancer treatment for the children at the 18 empanelled hospitals
- To provide tertiary health services to each and every child of state suffering from cancer
- commenced first of its kind ever special awareness programme for children suffering from cancer
- Under the Chief Minister Cancer Relief Fund scheme, cancer patients will be given Rs 1.5 lakh for treatment
- The health department is also imparting special training to medical officers, staff nurses and auxillary nursing midwives (ANMs) to conduct tests concerning cancers, especially among children and women in rural areas
Wednesday, 26 July 2017
Childhood cancer in India and abandonment of treatment
Recently a journalist Ankur Paliwal contacted me as he wanted to highlight this issue. He met others as well and has published a nice piece which tries to bring together all viewpoints and highlights very well, the social problem that abandonment of treatment is. I would urge you to read it by clicking on the link https://scroll.in/pulse/844442/children-are-dying-of-cancer-for-lack-of-money-even-those-that-get-free-medical-treatment
Sunday, 30 April 2017
Best Childhood Cancer Blogs on the Planet
My name is ____________. I'm Founder of Feedspot.
I would like to personally congratulate you as your blog Childhood Cancer India has been selected by our panelist as one of the Top 75 Childhood Cancer Blogs on the web.
http://blog.feedspot.com/childhood_cancer_blogs/
I personally give you a high-five and want to thank you for your contribution to this world. This is the most comprehensive list of Top 75 Childhood Cancer Blogs on the internet and I’m honored to have you as part of this!






















